In the latest episode of the "With Flying Colors" podcast, host Mark Treichel sits down with Vin Vieten, a former commercial lender and NCUA regulator, to discuss the critical topic of credit risk rating in commercial lending. This insightful conversation offers valuable takeaways for credit union professionals looking to enhance their risk management practices.
The Importance of Credit Risk Rating Systems
Vin emphasizes that credit risk rating is not just a regulatory requirement, but a fundamental best practice in commercial lending. He states, "Rating credit risk is a standard practice accepted practice. In managing commercial loan risk, all the other regulators focus on it and that's not the reason to do it because other regulators do it. But since it is the accepted practice, and those of us who were involved with commercial lending in the past knew how important it was."
Key Components of an Effective Credit Risk Rating System
1. Dynamic and Accurate: Vin stresses the importance of keeping risk ratings up-to-date. "To be effective, the risk rating system should be accurate at all times," he says.
2. Comprehensive Scale: A typical credit risk rating system uses a scale of 1-8, with 1-4 being "pass" grades and higher numbers indicating increasing risk.
3. Qualitative and Quantitative Factors: While quantitative factors are important, Vin highlights the critical role of qualitative assessment. "I personally believe that the quantitative is the easy part. It's that qualitative. And that's where your skills as a lender come in."
4. Regular Monitoring: Consistent review and updates of credit risk ratings are crucial for maintaining accuracy.
Benefits Beyond Compliance
Implementing a robust credit risk rating system isn't just about meeting regulatory requirements. Vin points out that it can significantly benefit both the credit union and its members. By closely monitoring risk, credit unions can identify potential issues early and work with borrowers to address them, potentially preventing defaults and strengthening relationships.
Resources for Implementation
For credit unions looking to improve their credit risk rating practices, Vin recommends several key resources:
1. NCUA Part 723 (MBL/Commercial Lending Rule)
2. NCUA Examiner's Guide on Rating Credit Risk
3. Interagency Guidance on Credit Risk Review
4. OCC Handbook on Rating Credit Risk (2001)
A Positive Outlook on Commercial Lending
Despite the complexities of risk management, Vin maintains an optimistic view of commercial lending. He states, "I think commercial lending is the safest lending you can do because you know the level of risk with the borrower. You have proper covenants. You can take actions to help the borrower."
Conclusion
As credit unions continue to navigate the commercial lending landscape, implementing and maintaining an effective credit risk rating system is more crucial than ever. By following the insights and best practices shared by Vin Vieten, credit unions can enhance their risk management strategies, ensure regulatory compliance, and better serve their commercial members.
Listen to the full episode for more in-depth insights and practical advice on mastering credit risk rating in commercial lending.
Reach out to learn how we assist our clients with NCUA so you save time and money.
Comments